14 Best Eye Creams for Mature Skin in 2025, Per Dermatologists

Prioritize moisture. When it comes to choosing a formula, different ingredients have different benefits, but all our experts agree that hydration is key. “Most of us need hydration for smoothing fine lines, which means ingredients like hyaluronic acid and glycerin help draw moisture into the delicate skin around the eyes.”

Look for specific ingredients. Depending on your major concerns, you are going to need different ingredients. For those who want something brightening, “opt for vitamin C, niacinamide, or licorice extract, which work to even skin tone and reduce discoloration,” says Gunn. For those who want to reduce puffiness, caffeine can be helpful in reducing swelling. Peptides and ceramides can help repair the skin barrier, but for the best anti-aging benefits, Gunn recommends retinol specifically made for under-eye to help with fine lines and overall texture by encouraging cell turnover.

Apply with care.“Be careful when applying skincare products or makeup to this sensitive area; never tug or pull the skin as it can increase risk for damage,” says Dr. Spearman. “Use your ring finger to apply the least pressure. Apply a pea size amount of product and gently pat the product around the eye area.”

Prevent under eyes from further damage with protective measures like SPF. “I recommend wearing a moisturizer with broad spectrum SPF daily to protect the skin around the eyes,” explains Dr. Spearman. “I also recommend wearing sunglasses especially if you are planning on being out in the sun for long periods of time,” she adds. Plus, getting enough sleep and hydrating can also help avoid puffiness and dark circles.